The New York Islanders were done for us by Kate the Salty Caps Fan, known wearer of awesome red lips, @katemonster08 on Twitter.
Here is the NYI look, which is the Revlon Colorstay pencil liner (nightmare, do not recommend for actual use. Color saturation is good, but when you’re used to liquid liner like I am, it is the SINGLE most difficult pencil liner I have ever used to actually PUT ON.) Unfortunately I don’t feel the orange photographed very well, it is a truly bright parrot orange in real life. This is a thick, crayon like line of the royal blue liner (which took five million years to get), the bright orange on the lid and a light shimmer orange from the crease to the browbone.